Saturday, July 16, 2011

can fantasy be harmful?

inspired by-

"When you're a kid, you have no power. You're physically small and weak, and adults are constantly telling you what to do. So it's incredibly compelling to imagine yourself not only as someone to whom exciting things happen but as someone who is more than those around you. The problem is that then you begin to grow up and realize you're just a lowly muggle. … Is it possible that all of us, weaned on these stories, end up inevitably disappointed with mundane life as it actually exists?" 
Paul Waldman, writing for The American Prospect, on why Harry Potter (and other children's books, too) may be contributing to young readers' unhappiness 

 I read fantasy to escape, but also to empower myself. It's easy to see why. Books take me on an instant journey to everywhere, and on days where I'm put down, frustrated, and unsuccessful, an instant escape is very tempting. Well-written fantasy books take me into the hearts and minds of the characters, and make me be the character. Whether I'm blasting droids with Anakin or cracking puzzles(finished Goblet of Fire today, heh heh) with Harry, I enter the character's mind and heart as wholly as he/she enters mine. His success is my success, and his failure is my disappointment.
But, as the quote above says, can all this be harmful? Whether it's Percy Jackson or Star Wars or Harry Potter or Artemis Fowl or Twilight, the main character often starts off being different, normal and relatable, just like you and me. And then something happens, they change and become better, greater, more awesome, then everyone around them. They have their own special power and destiny, leaving the ordinary behind. 

And so we are conditioned to believe that we, some day, will also leave behind the ordinary for a great destiny. One day I'll put aside school, parents, money, rules, and go save the world, to the awe and envy of lots of people who were just like me.

And we spend our days waiting...waiting for our Hogwarts acceptance letter, our satyr, our-whatever, something that says "HEY! You're not ordinary anymore! Congrats!"

And it never comes. as we know it goes on. Any achievements, great or small, come with a lot of time, sweat, and sacrifice. They don't seem worth it, compared with, I don't know, TIME TRAVEL??

Rather than face life for what it is, many of us go back to burying our heads in those books, where instead of being a B student, the slowest, the last, the least, we can be superpeople, and adults wither in the face of our witty sarcasm(Maximum Ride, anyone?). But when we grow up, we can't seek refuge in books anymore, so many grown ups turn to other things in an attempt to escape the mundane.

Of course, someday we will throw off the boringness, but we have our whole boring lives to survive first!
How can we use the fantasy genre to, instead of showing up real life with things like mind control, wings, and telekinesis, remind us how magical real life really is?


  1. Wow. This is a great post...and I just finished a fantasy book not ten minutes ago.

  2. Awesome post girl. Good reminder :]

  3. I used to get depressed after reading fantasy books and movies. I wanted to have adventures and to become special just like in Star Wars, Indiana Jones, Pirates of the Caribbean, Percy Jackson and so on! It did cause some unhappiness.

    But ever since I realized a relationship with Christ can be like an adventure (which was like a couple weeks ago) I have never felt bored with my life ever again. My desire to fight Sith or to be a demi-god has been replaced with a different desire. One that I actually feel fullfilled and enpowered with. Spending time sharing the Gospel with others. It may sound cheesy, but it's the honest truth. *shrugs*

    -Ley <3

  4. I don't read Fantasy, but I do write it...and it can cause some sadness on life. But you know, it helps me look at everything different. Fantasy is something I think should be carefully guarded, it can be a powerful key, or a double edged sword.

  5. I've noticed the same thing with video games. You become the last human on Earth or a WW2 fighter, but then you have to stop and go on with your normal life. I think that's part of what gets people addicted to online games like Runescape and world of warcraft; being bored and wanting a more thrilling life.


Amaranthine <3's you. Thanks for the comment!